Overall Rating: 3.5 / 5 Stars
First Impressions & Packaging
The 5171 ink cartridges come in simple, no-frills packaging that clearly states its key features: "Refillable" and "Erasable Blue" ink. The branding appears to be from "L Traders" or "Bamamani PL Traders," suggesting this is an affordable, likely generic, option in the fountain pen market. The Chinese characters "玄妙楼" (Xuān Miào Lóu) translate to "Mysterious Tower" or "Profound Building," which is a charming and intriguing name.
Key Features & Performance
Ink Color ("Erasable Blue"): This is the most distinctive feature. The blue ink has a specific formulation that allows it to be erased with a special rubber eraser, much like many inks used in erasable rollerball or gel pens. This is a major plus for students, note-takers, or anyone who makes frequent revisions and wants the writing experience of a fountain pen.
Refillable Design: The cartridges are designed to be refilled, which is an excellent eco-friendly and cost-effective feature. Instead of throwing away a plastic cartridge each time, you can use a blunt-tip syringe to inject your favorite bottle ink into them. This greatly increases the value proposition.
Compatibility (A Critical Note): The product name "玉米换囊钢笔" is crucial. It translates to "Corn Replacement Cartridge Pen." This strongly suggests these cartridges are designed for a specific type of pen, often referred to as a "school pen" or "beginner pen," which uses a unique, non-standard cartridge shape (short and round, resembling a corn kernel). They are highly unlikely to be standard international short or long cartridges. Please verify your pen's compatibility before purchasing, as they will not fit most common fountain pen brands like Lamy, Pilot, Platinum, or those that use standard international cartridges.
Pros
Erasable Ink: A unique and highly practical feature for a specific audience.
Refillable: Promotes sustainability and reduces long-term cost.
Extremely Affordable: These are undoubtedly very low-cost consumables.
Good for Specific Pens: Ideal for the inexpensive "corn cartridge" style school pens they are designed for.
Cons
Limited Compatibility: The biggest drawback. They fit a very niche type of pen and are not a universal cartridge.
Ink Quality: As a budget product, the ink itself is likely to be basic. It may not be as saturated, water-resistant, or fade-resistant as inks from established stationery brands like Waterman, Diamine, or Pelikan.
Potential for Mess: The erasing process can sometimes smudge or damage thinner paper.
Final Verdict
The 5171 Refillable Erasable Ink Cartridges are a niche product that does its job well for a very specific user.
Who should buy this?
Users who own a fountain pen that specifically takes "corn" or "kernel" style cartridges.
Students and drafters who prioritize the ability to erase their writing.
Budget-conscious buyers looking for the most affordable way to keep their compatible pen running.
Who should avoid this?
Owners of most common fountain pen brands (e.g., Lamy, Pilot, Faber-Castell, Kaweco, etc.).
Ink enthusiasts looking for high-quality, vibrant, or permanent inks.
Anyone unsure about their pen's cartridge compatibility.
In summary, it's a functional and clever product let down by its proprietary format. If you have the right pen, it's a fantastic, economical choice. For everyone else, it's important to seek out standard cartridges or bottled ink.
| Image 1 | Image 2 |
|---|---|
 |  |
| Image 3 | Image 4 |
Product Videos